Denial Autopsy
Turns a denied behavioral-health insurance claim into a payer-specific appeal letter and proof checklist, so a solo therapist can overturn a denial in 10 minutes instead of writing it off.
One product, one founder, thirty days. Everything below is built to be executed inside the contest window — the official rules still decide what counts.
Decide in 20 seconds
The facts that decide whether this is worth thirty days of yours.
Owner-clinician of a 1-5 clinician US behavioral health practice (LCSW/LMFT/LPC) billing commercial insurance or Medicaid, triggered the week they open a remittance advice with a denied 90837/90834/90791 claim or a payer records request.
Market demand 5.1/10
Why this could work in 30 days: one founder can ship the MVP in 4 days; the plan targets a first sale on day 10; 26 sales at $39 clears $1,000 of collected revenue; strongest signal is speed to first revenue at 8.4/10.
Score and projections come from the generated report and are not guarantees. The $100K Hackathon is run by Ship or Die — read the official rules before you build.
Your first 24 hours
15 concrete actions. Tick them off as you go — nothing is saved or sent.
Product opportunity and positioning
Target customer
Owner-clinician of a 1-5 clinician US behavioral health practice (LCSW/LMFT/LPC) billing commercial insurance or Medicaid, triggered the week they open a remittance advice with a denied 90837/90834/90791 claim or a payer records request.
Why now
Denial rates and payer documentation scrutiny are rising while solo practices run without a biller; every clinician already has the denial in hand this week and the decision is made by one person in one sitting.
Problem
A denied session is lost fee-for-service revenue and the therapist cannot tell what that specific payer wanted that the note did not say. Appeals take unpaid evening hours, so most denials are never filed at all.
Solution
A 4-step web intake (payer, CPT code, CARC/RARC code, date of service, timely-filing deadline) produces a Proof Checklist of the exact medical-necessity elements that payer/code pair requires; the clinician confirms each element in a short phrase and receives a payer-addressed appeal letter PDF, fax cover sheet, filing countdown and .ics follow-up reminder.
1. Product opportunity and positioning
Denial Autopsy serves one buyer: the owner-clinician of a 1-5 clinician US behavioral health practice that bills commercial insurance or Medicaid. The trigger is concrete and recurring - a remittance advice arrives with a denied 90837, 90834, 90791 or 90847, or a payer sends a records request. At that moment the clinician has three bad options: write it off, paste a generic template copied from a peer group, or burn two unpaid evening hours guessing what the payer wanted.
The product compresses that moment into a ten-minute document task. The clinician enters payer, plan type, CPT code, CARC/RARC code, date of service and the timely-filing deadline, pastes the denial text, and receives a Proof Checklist naming the specific medical-necessity elements that payer and code combination requires. They confirm each element with a short phrase. The output is a one-page payer-addressed appeal letter PDF, a fax cover sheet, a filing-deadline countdown and an .ics follow-up reminder.
Positioning is deliberately narrow: this is the appeal letter your payer will actually read, not a compliance platform. The absence of EHR integration is the feature. No IT gatekeeper, no BAA negotiation, no procurement, no implementation call. The buyer's economic argument fits in one sentence - one overturned 90837 claim is worth more than a year of the entry price.
The JEV score of 65.1/100 (band B, confidence 0.67) is honest about the shape of this bet. Speed to first revenue is the strongest dimension at 8.4/10 normalized: the buyer already has the denial, the price is below an owner's approval threshold, and the artifact is a document they were going to produce anyway. Solo build feasibility sits at 7.66. The weak dimensions are market demand (5.08), operational simplicity (5.66) and monetization potential (5.51). This plan is built to test those three numbers cheaply rather than assume them: demand is tested by free-letter volume in week one, operational simplicity by whether rule cards survive contact with real denials, and monetization by whether free users convert at $39 to $99 within 72 hours.
The wedge stays narrow for all 30 days. Single denials, behavioral health codes, therapist buyers reached directly through communities and directories. No hospital motion, no clearinghouse, no coding advice, no legal positioning.
Smallest sellable MVP
A four-step intake that takes a denial code plus confirmed clinical phrases and emails back a payer-addressed appeal letter PDF, fax cover sheet, filing countdown and .ics reminder, sold for $39 per letter through Stripe.
Must-have features
- Four-step intake wizard: payer, plan type, CPT code, CARC/RARC code, DOS, deadline
- Paste field for the denial letter text with element extraction
- Curated rule-card library covering ~40 behavioral-health CPT and CARC combinations
- Client-side redaction of names, DOB, member IDs and MRN before any model call, plus a server-side re-check
- Proof Checklist UI where the clinician ticks or types one short phrase per required element
- Constrained LLM drafting that writes only from confirmed elements and never invents plan language
- React-PDF output: appeal letter, fax cover sheet, timely-filing countdown
- Stripe Checkout with credit packs and monthly plan, enforced by a Supabase credit ledger
- Resend email delivery of the PDF and .ics follow-up file
Explicitly out of scope
- No EHR integration, browser extension or DOM scraping
- No pre-submission claim scrubbing or coding advice
- No clearinghouse, eligibility checks or payment posting
- No patient portal or stored clinical records
- No enterprise BAA or SOC program in the first 30 days
- No legal or billing advice positioning
- No team collaboration beyond shared seats
- No mobile app
Demo flow (what the buyer sees)
- Clinician opens app, selects payer and plan type
- Enters CPT 90837 and CARC CO-50 with date of service and deadline
- Pastes the denial paragraph; redaction runs in the browser
- Rule card renders the Proof Checklist for that payer/code pair
- Clinician confirms six elements with one-line phrases
- Clicks generate, pays $39 via Stripe Checkout
- PDF letter, fax cover sheet, countdown and .ics arrive by email in under 60 seconds
Technical implementation plan
Stack
Architecture
A Next.js app on Vercel holds a static rule-card JSON bundle (no database read needed to render the checklist) and a Supabase Postgres instance for accounts, credit balances and letter metadata only - never clinical text after generation. The browser performs a regex and heuristic redaction pass on the pasted denial text before it is sent to a serverless route. That route re-checks for identifier patterns, loads the matching rule card, and calls the Anthropic API with a prompt restricted to the clinician-confirmed elements. The response is rendered server-side into a PDF with React-PDF, stored for 24 hours, and emailed via Resend with the .ics attachment. Stripe Checkout creates the purchase and a webhook credits the ledger.
Build steps
- Scaffold Next.js on Vercel and create Supabase tables: accounts, credits, letters, rule_cards_version
- Define the rule-card schema: payer class, CPT code, CARC codes, required elements, deadline rule, appeal address block
- Author the first 40 rule cards from public payer denial-code documentation and CMS appeal-timing guidance
- Build the four-step intake wizard with client-side redaction and a pre-send confirmation screen
- Implement the constrained generation route: element list in, letter sections out, hard refusal on unconfirmed content
- Render letter and fax cover sheet with React-PDF and fix page-break and address-block layout
- Wire Stripe Checkout, the webhook and the Supabase credit ledger, gating generation on a positive balance
- Add Resend delivery with the PDF and the .ics follow-up attachment, plus a 24-hour letter purge job
- Ship the edit-and-regenerate loop so a buyer can fix one phrase without spending another credit
- Deploy, run 20 dry-run denials end to end, and log every prompt failure
AI components
- Extraction of payer, denial reason and deadline hints from pasted denial text
- Element-to-checklist matching against the rule card
- Drafting the letter body from confirmed phrases only, with refusal on missing elements
- Plain-language explanation of what a CARC code means for this CPT
Pricing and monetization
Single Appeal
Entry offerFor Solo therapist with one denial in hand
- One payer-specific appeal letter PDF
- Proof Checklist for that denial code
- Fax cover sheet and timely-filing countdown
Recovery Pack
For Solo therapist or 2-clinician practice clearing a backlog
- Three appeal letters
- Denial-code playbook PDF for their top five codes
- Follow-up .ics reminders
Practice Pro
For Group practice of 2-5 clinicians with recurring denials
- Unlimited appeal letters
- Denial pattern dashboard by payer and code
- Shared rule-card library and team seats
Model: One-time credit packs for a single denial, with a monthly unlimited plan for practices with recurring denials.
First revenue offer: Send me the denial code you got this week and I will send back the exact paragraph your payer needs, free - first letter on me, no card required.
Expected ACV: $99
Upsell path: Free single letter converts to the $99 Recovery Pack for backlog, then to $149 monthly once a practice sees three or more denials per month; referral credit of $20 per paid intro compounds without ad spend.
First-customer acquisition
Direct posts and DMs in private-practice therapist Facebook communities, paired with public therapist-directory listings for group practices, using a free-first-appeal offer.
Where to find them
- Three large private-practice therapist Facebook groups (owner-clinician audience)
- Psychology Today and similar public directory listings filtered to group practices with 2-5 clinicians
- State LCSW/LMFT/LPC association listservs and consultation group rosters
- Reddit r/therapists weekly practice-management thread
- Local and regional behavioral health practice owner meetups listed publicly
Exact outreach motions
- Post the free-first-letter offer in one group per day with a redacted before/after letter image, not a link
- DM each directory-listed practice owner a two-sentence message referencing their modality and the 90837 denial angle
- Reply to every denial-code comment within two hours and deliver the free letter through the app, not by hand
- Day-3 follow-up asking whether the claim was reopened or the appeal filed, then offer the Recovery Pack
- Ask every converted buyer for one intro in their consultation group or state association listserv
Message template
Hi [name] - I built a small tool for solo practices: you paste the CARC code and denial text from a 90837 or 90834 denial, confirm a few clinical phrases, and it produces a payer-addressed appeal letter plus a filing-deadline countdown. Reply with the denial code you got this week and I will run the first one free so you can see the letter. No EHR login, nothing stored.
30-day execution roadmap
Week 1 · Build & validate · 7 days
Repo and rule-card schema
- Scaffold Next.js and Supabase, deploy an empty shell to Vercel.
- Define the rule-card JSON schema and publish version 0.
- Pull CARC and appeal-timing facts from public payer documentation.
Deliverable: Live skeleton plus rule-card schema committed.
Author the first 40 cards
- Write rule cards for 90834, 90837, 90847, 90791 and the eight highest-frequency CARC codes.
- Add deadline rules and payer address blocks per card.
- Spot-check 10 cards against published payer guidance.
Deliverable: rule_cards.json v1 with 40 entries.
Four-step wizard
- Build the four-step wizard with validation on CPT and CARC.
- Add the denial-text paste field and browser-side redaction pass.
- Render the Proof Checklist from the matched rule card.
Deliverable: Working wizard reaching a populated checklist screen.
Letter PDF end to end
- Implement the constrained Anthropic generation route.
- Render letter and fax cover sheet with React-PDF.
- Run five real-format sample denials through the pipeline.
Deliverable: Downloadable appeal letter PDF from a test denial.
Payments and delivery
- Wire Stripe Checkout, webhook and Supabase credit ledger.
- Add Resend delivery of PDF and .ics with a 24-hour purge job.
- Deploy MVP and buy one letter yourself with a real card.
Deliverable: MVP live, paid purchase produces a delivered letter.
Prompt and layout failures
- Run 20 dry-run denials and log every generation failure.
- Fix page breaks, address blocks and refusal messages.
- Record a 60-second Loom showing one denial becoming one letter.
Deliverable: Loom demo plus closed bug list.
Lists and first post
- Build a 200-practice list from public directories.
- Join three private-practice therapist Facebook groups.
- Post the free-first-letter offer in group one.
Deliverable: 200-row outreach sheet, first post live.
Week 2 · Launch & first sale · 7 days
First DM wave
- Send 25 personalized DMs from the list.
- Reply to every comment within two hours.
- Log reply rate per source in the tracking sheet.
Deliverable: 25 DMs sent, reply log started.
Free letters at volume
- Deliver 10 free letters through the app, not by hand.
- Capture the denial code and payer for each.
- Flag any card that failed to produce a usable letter.
Deliverable: 10 free letters delivered, failure list.
First paid order
- Follow up every free-letter recipient with the $39 Single Appeal link.
- Offer the $99 Recovery Pack to anyone with a backlog.
- Fix the single most common objection in the copy.
Deliverable: First paid Stripe order recorded.
Public before and after
- Post a redacted denial-to-letter walkthrough in group two.
- Add a visible 'we store nothing' explainer to the site.
- Answer three denial questions publicly without pitching.
Deliverable: Second community post plus privacy page live.
Second DM wave
- Send 40 DMs to group-practice listings.
- A/B the opening line against the day-8 version.
- Book two 15-minute calls with interested owners.
Deliverable: 40 DMs sent, two calls booked.
Remove friction
- Fix the top three drop-off points observed in sessions.
- Add regenerate-one-section without spending a credit.
- Deploy and re-test the full flow.
Deliverable: Changelog entry and deployed fix set.
Week-two metrics
- Tally replies, free letters, paid orders and refunds.
- Recalculate blended order value.
- Decide whether to lean on groups or DMs.
Deliverable: Metrics sheet with a channel decision.
Week 3 · Repeat & systematize · 7 days
Public playbook
- Publish a free denial-code playbook page for the top five codes.
- Add an email capture for the playbook.
- Link it from every outreach message.
Deliverable: Public playbook page live.
Group practices
- Send 30 DMs to 2-5 clinician practices.
- Lead with the recurring-denial angle, not the one-off.
- Log who asks about multiple clinicians.
Deliverable: 30 sends, group-practice interest list.
Warm intros
- Ask five buyers or free users for a consultation-group intro.
- Draft a one-paragraph forwardable blurb.
- Send the blurb to two state association listserv contacts.
Deliverable: Five intro requests sent.
Monthly plan
- Ship the Practice Pro $149 monthly checkout.
- Add a detail view counting denials by payer.
- Test the upgrade path from a purchased pack.
Deliverable: Monthly checkout live and tested.
Second free batch
- Deliver 10 more free letters.
- Ask each recipient for one referral.
- Log which rule cards were reused.
Deliverable: 10 letters plus referral log.
Code-specific demos
- Record three 60-second Looms by denial code.
- Attach the matching Loom to targeted DMs.
- Track view-to-reply rate per Loom.
Deliverable: Three Looms in rotation.
Halfway decision
- Compute conversion rate per channel and per Loom.
- Kill the worst channel, double the best.
- Set the day-30 revenue target from observed data.
Deliverable: Written channel decision and revised target.
Week 4 · Scale what works · 7 days
Monthly conversions
- Pitch Practice Pro to anyone with three or more denials.
- Offer a two-week trial on the monthly plan.
- Log objections verbatim.
Deliverable: Five upgrade conversations started.
Rule-card coverage
- Add eight cards for codes users actually requested.
- Fix any card that produced a weak letter.
- Bump the rule_cards_version.
Deliverable: Eight new cards deployed.
Fourth community
- Post the offer in a fourth community with a new angle.
- Answer a weekly practice-management thread.
- Invite replies via DM only, no links in-thread.
Deliverable: Two new public posts live.
Non-buyers
- Email every free user who did not purchase.
- Lead with the filing deadline, not a discount.
- Include one redacted outcome story.
Deliverable: Reactivation send to the full free list.
Paid intros
- Launch a $20 referral credit page.
- Tell every existing buyer directly.
- Track referral links in Stripe.
Deliverable: Referral mechanism live.
Refund prevention
- Review every generated letter from the last week.
- Fix the prompt or card behind each weak output.
- Remove any plan language the model paraphrased.
Deliverable: Quality pass deployed.
Testimonials
- Ask three buyers for a one-line quote with permission.
- Add the quotes to the site with no invented numbers.
- Recheck that no outcome is stated as guaranteed.
Deliverable: Three permitted testimonials on site.
Days 29-30 · Consolidate · 2 days
Last call
- Send the last-call offer to the full list.
- Re-share the strongest redacted walkthrough once.
- Answer every open DM thread.
Deliverable: Final campaign sent and logged.
Reconciliation
- Reconcile Stripe payouts against the credit ledger.
- Confirm every payment is recorded in TrustMRR.
- Tally verified profit and write the post-mortem.
Deliverable: Reconciled profit figure and post-mortem.
Revenue and profit scenarios
How the numbers are defined
Hackathon profit — Collected revenue − refunds − chargebacks − payment processing fees − paid marketing spend.
Business profit — Hackathon profit − operating costs (hosting, domains, tooling, AI/API delivery costs).
The contest ranks entrants on hackathon profit only. Hosting, tooling and AI/API delivery costs are not deducted by the organisers, but each sale still has to cover them — so we show both. Definitions verified on 2026-11-15 against the official rules.
Stated assumptions
- All scenarios are projections built from stated assumptions, not verified revenue or existing customers.
- Conservative/Base/Upside: blended ARPU held at $99, the Recovery Pack price, with Single Appeal at $39 and Practice Pro at $149 as the tails.
- Conservative/Base: acquisition is 100% organic outreach, so ad_spend_usd is 0; Upside assumes $150 of sponsored community posts and paid newsletter placements.
- Payment processing assumed at Stripe 2.9% plus $0.30 per charge, roughly 3.9-4.0% blended on a $39-$149 order mix.
- Refunds assumed at 0 in Conservative and Base; Upside carries $50 for two Single Appeal refunds after weak letters.
- Chargebacks assumed at 0 across all scenarios given the low price point and card-present buyer intent.
- Operating costs cover Vercel, Supabase, domain, Resend and Anthropic inference at under $0.50 per letter; not deducted from hackathon profit.
- Free letters are not counted as customers; only paid orders inside the contest window count.
- Rule cards for ~40 codes are assumed to cover the majority of denials this buyer sees - untested.
- Conversion from free letter to paid pack assumed at 20-25% - untested.
Conservative
3 customers- Refunds
- $0
- Chargebacks
- $0
- Payment fees
- $12
- Paid marketing
- $0
- Hackathon profit
- $285
- Operating costs
- $25
- Business profit
- $260
Base case
10 customers- Refunds
- $0
- Chargebacks
- $0
- Payment fees
- $39
- Paid marketing
- $0
- Hackathon profit
- $951
- Operating costs
- $45
- Business profit
- $906
Optimistic
25 customers- Refunds
- $50
- Chargebacks
- $0
- Payment fees
- $97
- Paid marketing
- $150
- Hackathon profit
- $2,178
- Operating costs
- $90
- Business profit
- $2,088
Model your own numbers
Runs in your browser · nothing is saved- Collected revenue
- $390
- Payment fees (3.9%)
- $15
- Paid marketing
- $0
- Hackathon profit
- $375
- Business profit
- $330
Hypothetical arithmetic, not a forecast. The fee rate is a flat 3.9% assumption, refunds and chargebacks are left at zero here, and none of this is tracked data.
Scenario models from stated assumptions, not verified revenue. No customers, traction or partnerships are claimed. Hackathon profit excludes hosting, tooling and AI delivery costs; business profit deducts them.
Main risks and validation experiments
Risk 1Therapist PHI discomfort blocks signups even with client-side redaction.
Redact in the browser, store nothing after 24 hours, and publish a plain-language data page with the exact fields never collected.
Put the privacy explainer above the fold on day 11 and measure intake completion rate before and after.
If fewer than 1 in 5 DM repliers will paste a denial after seeing the privacy page, the intake model is wrong.
Risk 2Rule cards go stale or are wrong for a specific plan, producing a weak letter and refunds.
Version every card, log which card produced each letter, and keep the clinician in a confirm-each-element loop so no element is asserted without them.
Run 20 real denials and have the clinician rate each letter as usable or not before sending.
If more than 30% of generated letters are rated unusable across 20 attempts, the rule-card approach is not yet sellable.
Risk 3The model invents plan language or clinical facts, damaging word of mouth.
Template the section scaffolding, constrain the model to rephrasing confirmed phrases, and require the user to paste their own plan appeal-rights clause.
Manually review every letter generated in week two against the source denial for unsupported claims.
Any single letter containing fabricated plan language triggers a hard stop and prompt rebuild before further sales.
Risk 4Therapist communities restrict self-promotion and ban the account.
Lead with free help and redacted artifacts, disclose the tool only when someone asks, and keep DM volume human-scale.
Post the help-first version in one group and track removals and reply volume for 48 hours.
If two of the first three groups remove posts, shift all effort to directory DMs and listservs.
Risk 5Free-to-paid conversion collapses well below assumption.
Follow up within 72 hours while the filing deadline is live, and anchor the price against one denied session fee.
Offer the $39 Single Appeal to the first 10 free-letter recipients and record how many pay.
If fewer than 1 in 10 free recipients pays within 96 hours, reprice or convert to a per-payer subscription before spending more on outreach.
Risk 6Buyers read the product as legal or billing advice and hesitate.
Position strictly as document drafting from the clinician's own confirmed statements; add a one-line non-advice notice at the footer of every letter.
A/B the hero copy between 'appeal letter drafting' and 'revenue recovery' and compare checkout starts.
If checkout abandonment exceeds 70% after copy change, reposition to a document template library model.
Hour-by-hour: the first 24 hours
Hours 1-2
- Scaffold Next.js, deploy an empty shell to Vercel.
- Create Supabase project and the accounts, credits, letters tables.
- Commit the rule-card JSON schema.
Output: Deployed skeleton and committed schema.
Hours 3-5
- Author the first 12 rule cards for 90837, 90834, 90791 and 90847.
- Attach the four highest-frequency CARC codes to each.
- Record the appeal deadline rule per card.
Output: rule_cards.json with 12 usable entries.
Hours 6-8
- Build the four-step intake wizard with CPT and CARC validation.
- Add the browser-side redaction pass.
- Render the Proof Checklist from a loaded card.
Output: Working wizard to checklist screen on local and Vercel preview.
Hours 9-11
- Implement the constrained Anthropic generation route.
- Render a one-page letter with React-PDF.
- Run two sample denials end to end.
Output: Downloadable letter PDF from a test denial.
Hours 12-14
- Join three private-practice therapist Facebook groups.
- Draft the free-first-letter message and the DM template.
- Start a 50-practice list from public directories.
Output: Group memberships, final message copy, 50-row list.
Full 30-day launch report
Read the full generated report
Denial Autopsy - 30-Day Solo Launch Report
1. Product opportunity and positioning
Denial Autopsy serves one buyer: the owner-clinician of a 1-5 clinician US behavioral health practice billing commercial insurance or Medicaid. The trigger is concrete and recurring - a remittance advice arrives with a denied 90837, 90834, 90791 or 90847, or a payer sends a records request. At that moment the clinician has three bad options: write it off, paste a generic template copied from a peer group, or burn two unpaid evening hours guessing what the payer wanted.
The product compresses that into a ten-minute document task. The clinician enters payer, plan type, CPT code, CARC/RARC code, date of service and the timely-filing deadline, pastes the denial text, and gets a Proof Checklist naming the exact medical-necessity elements that payer and code require. They confirm each element with a short phrase. Output: a one-page payer-addressed appeal letter PDF, fax cover sheet, filing countdown and .ics reminder.
Positioning is deliberately narrow: the appeal letter your payer will actually read, not a compliance platform. No EHR integration is the feature. No IT gatekeeper, no BAA negotiation, no procurement, no implementation call. The buyer's economic argument fits in one sentence - one overturned 90837 covers a year of entry pricing.
The JEV score of 65.1/100 (band B, confidence 0.67) is honest about the shape of this bet. Speed to first revenue is strongest at 8.4/10 normalized: the buyer already holds the denial, the price sits under an owner's approval threshold, and the artifact is a document they were going to produce anyway. Solo build feasibility is 7.66. The weak dimensions are market demand (5.08), operational simplicity (5.66) and monetization potential (5.51). This plan tests those three cheaply instead of assuming them. Demand is tested by free-letter volume in week one. Operational simplicity is tested by whether rule cards survive real denials. Monetization is tested by whether free users convert at $39-$99 within 72 hours.
2. Smallest sellable MVP
One intake, one checklist, one PDF, one Stripe charge. The MVP is a four-step wizard that takes payer, CPT, CARC code, date of service and deadline, matches a rule card, lets the clinician confirm each required element in a short phrase, and emails back a letter plus fax cover sheet. Redaction runs in the browser before any text leaves it, and no clinical text is stored after 24 hours.
Nothing else ships by day 5. No EHR integration, no browser extension, no claim scrubbing, no clearinghouse, no coding advice, no portal, no BAA program. Every one of those is a trust cycle this buyer will not run for a $39 purchase.
3. Technical implementation plan
Next.js 15 on Vercel renders a static rule-card JSON bundle, so the checklist needs no database read. Supabase Postgres holds accounts, credit balances and letter metadata only. A serverless route re-checks redaction, loads the card, and calls the Anthropic API with a prompt restricted to confirmed elements. React-PDF renders the letter and cover sheet. Resend delivers the PDF and .ics. Stripe Checkout plus a webhook credits the ledger.
The hardest technical risk is not the PDF renderer - it is keeping the model inside confirmed elements. The scaffold templates the section structure so the model only rephrases phrases the clinician typed, and refuses when an element is missing. Any invented plan citation is a reputation event in a community that talks to itself.
4. Pricing and monetization
Three tiers, one ladder. Single Appeal at $39 one-time converts the denial-in-hand buyer. Recovery Pack at $99 one-time clears a backlog and is the assumed blended order value. Practice Pro at $149 monthly serves 2-5 clinician practices with recurring denials and turns a transaction into a subscription.
The first revenue offer is free: send the denial code, get the first letter at no charge, delivered through the app so the founder never hand-writes appeals. Paid conversion happens on follow-up, not on the first message.
5. First-customer acquisition
One channel: direct posts and DMs in private-practice therapist Facebook communities, backed by public directory listings for group practices. The offer is specificity, not a pitch - name the code, deliver the letter, ask about the claim three days later. Every deliverable goes through the app so the founder's time scales and the product gets tested on real denials daily. Referrals are asked for only after a letter is delivered.
6. 30-day execution roadmap
Days 1-5 are build and monetization: schema, 40 rule cards, wizard, generation, Stripe. Day 5 is the gate - if a real card cannot buy a letter, stop and fix before outreach.
Days 6-14 are first contact. Day 6 hardens the pipeline on 20 dry-run denials. Days 7-9 build the 200-practice list, join three groups, post once, send 25 DMs, deliver 10 free letters. Day 10 is the first paid-order target. Days 11-14 add a public walkthrough and a second DM wave, then audit which channel actually replied.
Days 15-21 add leverage: a free denial-code playbook page, group-practice DMs, referral asks, the $149 monthly checkout, three code-specific Looms, and a day-21 decision that kills the worst channel and doubles the best.
Days 22-28 are expansion and quality: monthly upgrades, eight new rule cards from real requests, a fourth community, reactivation of non-buyers, a paid referral credit, a quality pass on every letter shipped that week, and permitted testimonials with no invented numbers.
Days 29-30 are last call and reconciliation: one final send to the full list, then Stripe payouts reconciled against the credit ledger and every payment confirmed in TrustMRR.
7. Revenue and profit scenarios
Projections only, from stated assumptions. Hackathon profit = gross revenue - refunds - chargebacks - payment fees - paid marketing. Business profit additionally deducts hosting, tooling and AI delivery.
- Conservative: 3 customers at $99 = $297 gross. Fees $12, refunds $0, chargebacks $0, ads $0. Hackathon profit $285; business profit $260 after $25 operating.
- Base: 10 customers at $99 = $990 gross. Fees $39, all other deductions $0. Hackathon profit $951; business profit $906 after $45 operating.
- Upside: 25 customers at $99 = $2,475 gross. Fees $97, refunds $50, ads $150. Hackathon profit $2,178; business profit $2,088 after $90 operating.
The base case is not the target - it is the floor for a plan that works. The upside matches the concept's own 25-customer sketch and depends on two untested numbers: free-to-paid conversion at 20-25%, and rule-card coverage of the denials this buyer actually receives.
8. Main risks and validation experiments
PHI discomfort is the top risk. Mitigation: browser-side redaction, 24-hour purge, a visible data page. Test by placing that page above the fold on day 11 and measuring intake completion. Kill signal: fewer than 1 in 5 repliers will paste a denial after reading it.
Rule-card staleness is second. Test 20 real denials and have the clinician rate each letter usable or not before sending. Kill signal: more than 30% unusable.
Model hallucination is third and binary. Every letter generated in week two is manually checked against the source denial. One fabricated plan citation stops sales until the prompt is rebuilt.
Community bans and weak conversion round out the list. Both are cheap to test in week two: one help-first post, one $39 offer to ten free recipients. If fewer than 1 in 10 pays within 96 hours, reprice before spending more time on outreach.
9. First 24-hour action plan
Hours 1-2: scaffold Next.js, deploy the Vercel shell, create Supabase tables, commit the rule-card schema. Hours 3-5: author the first 12 cards for 90837, 90834, 90791 and 90847 with their top CARC codes. Hours 6-8: build the wizard and browser redaction, render the checklist. Hours 9-11: constrained generation plus React-PDF letter, two denials end to end. Hours 12-14: join three therapist communities, finalize the free-first-letter copy, start the 50-practice list.
By hour 24 the founder should have a deployed preview that turns a real denial code into a real letter, and the first outreach message written. Everything after that is repetition, measurement and price adjustment.
All figures in this report are projections from stated assumptions. No customers, revenue, partnerships or outcomes are claimed or verified.
This brief was generated from public data about established startups, then narrowed and scored for a solo 30-day launch. Revenue and profit figures are scenario models, not verified results, guarantees or evidence of existing customers. Validate demand yourself before you spend a month on it — and check the contest rules for what counts toward your score.
Related ideas
All ideas →StaleDoc Audit
StaleDoc Audit scans a company's existing Google Drive in about ten minutes and delivers a ranked PDF report of outdated, duplicated and orphaned documents, so an ops lead knows exactly which pages to fix or kill first.
Proofwright
Proofwright runs the customer interview on autopilot and returns a publish-ready case study draft, pull quotes and social copy, white-labeled under the writer's own brand.
Bridge Brief
Turns a founder's own LinkedIn connections export into a ranked warm-intro map against a specific target list, with a ready-to-send ask for every path.